Wednesday 17 November 2010

Lecture 3 - The Document

Here are my notes from The Document lecture we had on 17/11/2010.

"I have been a witness, and these pictures are my testimony. The events I have recorded should not be forgotten and must not be repeated."

Aims:
   - introduce documentary photography and conflict photography
   - introduce the work of Mass Observation, Magnum and the FSA Photographers
   - explore questions of objectivity and subjectivity inherent in documentary practice
   - interrogate the authority of the photographic image


Documentary photography has dominated the 20th Century.

Joseph Nicephore Niepce - View from a window at La Gras (1826)

Genre is difficult to define.
   - wide variety of styles and topics.

Idea/term document signifies evidence of something not to be questioned.

Use of camera not only to record but to document and radicalise situations
   - camera with a conscience.
   - not just there to record but also there to expose situations
   - contact between audience and photography

The role is not to be just an invisible eye,
   - involve themselves
   - taking a stance
   - aligning themselves.

Old photography became popular of showing the other how others live.

William Edward Kilburn - The Great Chartist meeting at the common (1848)
   - photographer not involved
        - higher
        - not seen
        - removed
   - authenticity, historical fact?

How can a photographer not influence events in any way?
   - factual records of events
   - only records of history

People want to capture the world and war becomes key focus.


The Decisive Movement

Henri Cartier-Bresson,
   - depiction of everyday
   - also composed
   - have photos in head before took it


"photography achieves its highest distinction - reflecting the universality of the human condition in a never-to-be-retrieved fraction of a second"

   - more artistic
   - composed


How much of documentary photography concerns itself with aesthetics?

Jacob Riis
   - middle class social campaigner
        - squoller and poverty
   - book - how the other half live

Sensationalising recording.
   - morbid fascination for others
        - allowing the rich to spy on the poor.


Jacob Riis - Bandits Roost (1888)
   - not invisible eye
   - not neutral
   - posing for it
   - not depiction of real life but how they want it to appear
   - Riis fantasy?

Jacob Riis - A growler gang in session (robbing a lush) (1887)
   - posing
   - all in same clothes
   - acting
   - artificial representation


Lewis Hine - Russian Steel Workers (1908)
   - subtle
   - more empathy
   - more humanity
   - more neutrality - awkward
   - not stereotyped people


F.S.A Photographers (1935-44)
   - 2 ways of appoaching communication
   - director Roy Stryker
   - Depression- 11million unemployed
   - mass migration of farm labourers 'oakies'
   - the photograph as both emotive photojournalism and emotive lobbying tool

F.S.A = Farm Security Administration

   - photographers given shooting scripts
        - what to take
        - how to take it
   - has a total agenda

Margaret Bourke-White - Sharecroppers Home (1937)
   - documents with agenda
        - not neutral

Russell Lee - Interior of a black farmers house (1939)
   - same as the previous example but a different way of representing

Dorothea Lange - Migrant Mother (1936)
   - became poster for the great depression
   - try draw parallels 
   - arranging the people like actors until they get what they like

Robert Frank
   - exposing America

John Lamprey - Front and profile views of a malayan male (1868)
   - comparing other to self
   - used to prove judging people to characteristics
        - justify scientifically black inferior to the white

Photography is power.

Mass Observation 1937-60
   - science project
   - Tom Harrison
   - Charles Madge
   - Humphrey Jennings
   - Humphrey Spender

Neutral democratic response to the woking class.
   - more accurate document of the world.


War/Conflict Photography.

Robert Capa - Normandy, France (1945)
   - becomes it's own
   - provide horrifying examples of living
   - he was there when everything was happening so unfair to ask if they are 'real' - but they have


Magnum Group
   - international group of documentary photography
   - founded 1947 by Capa and Cartier-Bresson
   - ethos of documenting the world and its social problems


Robert Haeberle - People about to be shot (1969)
   - intercepted the moment where people about to be shot
   - last moment of peoples lives
   - inhumanity
   - should he have intervened and tried to stop it happening?

Documentary Photography
   - desire to show horror of the world to try and make a difference.

Key Features
   - offer humanitarian perspective
   - potray social and political situations
   - porport to be objective to facts of situations
   - people tend to form the subject matter

No comments:

Post a Comment